These highlights explore the unique governance challenges faced in South Georgia, the problematic beginnings of Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) elections, and the ongoing debate surrounding policing reform in the UK. It highlights the issues of capacity, accountability, and the implications of proposed national police force structures, emphasizing the need for local identity and public consultation in policing matters.

Laura explains the unique reality of governing South Georgia, where a tiny team must deliver a number of services in extreme isolation, with limited support and decisions that carry real, immediate consequences.

https://policing.tv/videos/inside-south-georgia-governing-the-edge-of-the-world/

Martin explains why the first PCC elections were so problematic, from dismal turnout to costly timing, and how those early missteps shaped public perception, accountability, and scrutiny of the role from the very start.

https://policing.tv/videos/inside-the-rise-and-fall-of-pccs/

We step back from headlines to ask a fundamental question: what problem is policing reform trying to solve? Using Durham’s history, this section challenges force mergers proposed without evidence, consultation, or public consent.

https://policing.tv/videos/durhams-labour-police-and-crime-commissioner-joy-allen/

PCC Matthew Barber unpicks the white paper’s “national police force” idea. He says much of it already exists, warns organised crime is still local, and flags serious risks around mergers and operational independence.

https://policing.tv/videos/police-reform-or-power-grab-a-pcc-responds/

Ian Wiggett explains the white paper’s real story: a shift from local to national control—creating a National Police Service with power to mandate forces, changing accountability and governance.

https://policing.tv/videos/police-reform-white-paper-power-shift-explained/

Takeaways

• Governance in South Georgia is challenging due to limited capacity.
• Staff in South Georgia must perform multiple roles.
• Training for police functions takes a significant amount of time.
• The first PCC elections faced dismal turnout and high costs.
• Low turnout led to many inexperienced PCCs being elected.
• Policing reform should focus on local needs and public input.
• Collaboration among forces is essential but should not erase local identity.
• Organised crime is often a local issue that requires local policing.
• The proposed national police force raises concerns about accountability.
• A significant shift in power dynamics is occurring in British policing.

Chapters
00:00 Governance Challenges in South Georgia
02:48 The Problematic Start of PCC Elections
05:30 Questioning Policing Reform
10:44 Concerns Over National Police Force
12:39 A Shift in Power Dynamics

We have launched a YouTube channel where you can also view our videos – just click here and please like and subscribe PTV Youtube